Our Products
Get ready to dip, drizzle, and dunk. Our condiments will become your everyday pantry staples and are the perfect souvenirs of Cape May too!
Pickle Girl Pantry is committed to using Jersey ingredients whenever possible.
Every small batch is made in Cape May. We even design our labels ourselves.
HOLY CAMOLY
HOT SAUCE
A sweet-spicy hot sauce that will perk up oysters, po'boys, grilled fish...
Red peppers, Thai chilis, Jalapenos, and paprika bring just the right amount of spiciness that keeps you coming back for more.
ON THE ½ SHELL
HOT SAUCE
Fresh horseradish meets our Holy Camoly for you to drizzle and slurp down.
Thai peppers, horseradish, red onions, ginger, and lime juice complements bivalve brine perfectly.
CHIMI CHIMI
HOT SAUCE
An ode to his Argentinian heritage, co-founder Lucas Manteca's chimichurri inspired sauce has an extra kick that makes it super tasty. Try it as a marinade for smoky grilled fish or chicken and as an accompaniment to all cuts of beef.
BREAD & BUTTER
PICKLES
Our signature pickle, inspired by a family recipe, and made with homegrown cucumbers. Eat these straight out of the jar, perfect for snack time.
GARLIC
PICKLES
Top any sandwich, sausage or dog with this savoury pickle. A sweet brine with a healthy dose of fresh garlic cloves give these pickles a delicious kick.
SPICY
PICKLES
The perfect combination of brine and heat, for those who like it hot. Spiked with hot peppers, these crunchy, chunky pickles are simply addictive.
JERSEY JAM
SPREAD
Juicy Jersey tomatoes paired with parsley, cilantro, cinnamon, cumin for a just-right sweet-tart balance. We love it on our Chorizo Torta breakfast sandwich at The Red Store, but we think you'll eat it with everything: BLT, grilled cheese, burgers...
Find Us
Visit us at any Bread+Butter Restaurant Group locations to purchase our products
The Red Store
500 Cape Ave
Cape May Point, NJ 08212
Quahog's Seafood Shack
206 97th St
Stone Harbor, NJ 08247
The Taco Shop
1288 Hornet RdRio Grande, NJ 08242
